Customer Reviews: Read 15 more reviews...
 If only the author was told he was not funny! December 25, 2008
M. J. Leahy (Sheffield, South Yorkshire United Kingdom)
The general content of the book is fine but just too much is the author trying to make you laugh and failing badly. I just could not force myself to read once Scott Kelby started trying to be funny. You may find his approach to your liking but for me it was a big disappointment. Did nobody at the publishers have the courage to tell Mr Kelby he was spoiling his good work with an irratating and maddening approach?
This is a great pity as it spoils a well researched and fact filled book. The illustrations are excellent and flow well with the written dialogue.
I have just purchased a book on Lightroom by Martin Evening, how refreshing to find an author who really gets down to business with his book.
 Yes the humour is bad... December 1, 2008
M. Gurney
After reading some of the previous reviews, I thought I would buy this book as surely some of the comments about the humour being awful must've been exaggerated!? Well, sadly not - the humour is truly awful. But don't let this put you off - the book in itself is amazing. I read it cover to cover in one sitting and had to get up to try all the techniques, despite it being way past my bedtime. I find the book easy to follow, the techniques are brilliant and will have anyone making the most of CS3 in no time! Highly recommended. (although I would agree that while the book tells you "how", it will not give you understanding of "why")
 Good for Photographers September 7, 2008
Cheatin' Jockey (Worcestershire)
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
Firstly don't let the humour comments put you off - it' not that bad. What the book does for digital photographers is tell you how to post process for great results and how to do some neat effects; what it doesn't do is explain why or what some of the steps are for. If you are creative or want to understand the workings of CS3 then look elsewhere. I got the CS3 Bible as well (which does the opposite - give the how and why but not much about what you can achieve) and between the two I got what I needed.
The book is nicely illustrated and all the steps to get the effects are clear and easy to follow.
Buy it and start USING Photoshop September 6, 2008
Vagra (England)
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
If you have Photoshop, this book will simply help you understand it and start making it work for you.
Forget all the comments about Scott Kelby's humour, its an easy to read book that explains things well.
I also bought the Dummies book for CS3, it really isn't a patch on this one and just doesn't explain anything clearly.
Buy this book and you will be a Kelby fan for life (even if he is an American!)
Fighting through Photoshop CS3 August 13, 2008
Mr. M. Holmes (UK)
2 out of 2 found this review helpful
I have been amateur photographer for years and have long since left my darkroom behind.
In recent times my interest has been revived by the new high quality digital pocket camera. In my case a Panasonic TZ3
Having played about with Photoshop I soon found I was getting nowhere fast until that is I purchased Scott Kebly's The Adobe Photoshop CS3 book.
I truly love this book; its step by step guide is a dream to use. Full of colour photos to accompany the instruction is great.
I used my own photos whilst going following the instructions which truly change the quality of the finished image.
I agree with other reviewers that Scott's humour is very American but don't let this put you off buying a truly great book. I would say the book is for the beginner to intermediate Photoshop user but has something for everyone.
The only down side is that I have hundreds of digital photos waiting for some Photoshop treatment.
Good luck any enjoy your copy.
|
